Dog Possessive of Toys With Other Dogs [9 Solutions]

Are you the proud owner of more than one furry friend? Are they both obsessed with the same toys?

As much as we love to see our pups share and play together, sometimes they can be a little possessive of their favorite toys when other pups are involved. If you’ve been struggling with this issue, don’t worry – you’re not alone!

In this blog post, we’ll explore why some dogs get possessive of their toys with other dogs and give you some tips on how to manage unwanted behavior. So, grab a cup of coffee, and let’s dive in!

Understanding Possessiveness in Dogs

Dogs, like humans, can exhibit possessive behavior. Possessiveness in dogs is often rooted in their natural instincts, such as guarding resources and protecting their belongings.

When it comes to toys, some dogs may perceive them as valuable possessions and feel the need to guard them from other dogs.

Learn more about making your dog feel safe.

Dog Possessive of Toys With Other Dogs

Dogs can become possessive of toys around other dogs because they might perceive the other dog as a threat to the possession of their toy.

Dogs are descended from wolves, who are accustomed to guarding their prey from the threat of other predators, so this behavior is natural for dogs.

Additionally, possessiveness can be a result of a lack of proper socialization or training, anxiety disorders, or it can even be due to genetics.

Resource guarding and possession aggression are common behavior issues in dogs. Nevertheless, with patience and training, these behaviors can be corrected.

Signs of Toy Possessiveness in Dogs

Here are some common signs of toy possessiveness in dogs:

1. Growling: When a dog growls at you or other dogs while playing with a toy, it’s a clear sign of possessiveness.
2. Snapping: If a dog shows its teeth and snaps at you or other dogs when approached, it’s a sign that the dog is feeling threatened and defensive of its toy.
3. Lunging: Dogs that lunge towards you or other dogs while playing or guarding their toys are also displaying possessive behavior.
4. Biting: In extreme cases, dogs may even bite other dogs or their owners to protect their toys.
5. Holding onto the toy tightly: Dogs may cling to their toys tightly and refuse to let them go, even when coaxed with treats or other toys.
6. Blocking access to the toy: Dogs may position themselves between their toy and other dogs or their owners, preventing them from approaching the toy.
7. Constantly seeking attention: Dogs that constantly bring their toys to their owners and demand attention to play with them may also be displaying possessive behavior.
8. Refusing to share toys: Dogs that do not share their toys with other dogs or their owners may be displaying signs of possessiveness.
9. Obsessive behavior: If a dog starts obsessively playing with a toy and refuses to engage in any other activity, it may be a sign of possessiveness and over-attachment to the toy.

If your dog is displaying any of these signs, it is important to address the issue as soon as possible to prevent it from getting worse.

Working with a certified animal behaviorist or dog trainer can help identify the root cause of the possessiveness and develop strategies to modify the behavior.

Causes of Toy Possessiveness in Dogs

Here are some possible causes of toy possessiveness in dogs:

1. Genetics: Some breeds are more prone to possessiveness, and this behavior may have been bred into them over time.
2. Fear: Possessive behavior can also be a response to fear, especially in rescue dogs or those with a history of mistreatment.
3. Lack of socialization: Dogs that have not been socialized well may be more possessive of their toys because they don’t know how to share.
4. Lack of training: Dogs that have not been trained to share may find it difficult to give up their toys.
5. Territorialism: Toy possessiveness can also be a territorial behavior, especially if the toy is in the dog’s designated space.
6. Resource guarding: In some cases, toy possessiveness is a manifestation of resource guarding, where the dog sees the toy as a valuable resource to be protected.
7. Anxiety: Dogs that suffer from anxiety may become possessive of their toys as a way to cope with their anxiety.
8. Overprotectiveness: Some dogs, especially those that are highly bonded with their owners, may become possessive of their toys as a way to protect their owner’s property.
9. Lack of exercise: Dogs that do not get enough exercise and playtime may become overly possessive of their toys as a way to compensate for their lack of stimulation.

These are just some of the possible causes of toy possessiveness in dogs. The most effective solution to this problem is based on a combination of proper training, socialization, and understanding the underlying reason for the behavior.

Strategies to Manage Dog Possessive of Toys With Other Dogs

The following are some common strategies to manage dog possessive of toys with other dogs:

1. Provide Sufficient Toys and Space

Making sure that each dog has a sufficient number of toys to play with is an important part of controlling the possessiveness toward toys.

Offering a selection of toys lowers the likelihood of disputes resulting from resource guarding.

In order to reduce competition and possessiveness, make sure there is enough room for each dog to enjoy their toys on their own.

2. Supervise Playtime

It’s crucial to keep a close eye on your dogs’ interactions while they play in order to spot any early indications of possessive behavior.

Be on the lookout for tense posture, growling, or aggressive body language. You can stop conflicts from getting worse by intervening when necessary and refocusing their attention.

3. Teach Basic Obedience Commands

Training your dog to obey basic commands like “sit,” “stay,” and “drop it” is essential for preventing toy obsession.

When possessiveness develops, you can use these commands to take back control of their behavior and divert their attention.

They will learn to understand and respect boundaries with consistent training and positive reinforcement.

4. Practice Trading Toys

Possessive behavior can be greatly reduced by teaching your dogs to happily exchange toys.

Offer them a high-value treat to start, instead of the toy they are playing with.

Encouraging them to link giving up a toy with receiving something equally valuable, this technique helps them develop positive behavior patterns.

5. Rotate Toys

Regularly switching out your dogs’ toys can reduce dog possessiveness with toys toward other dogs.

You can lessen the likelihood of attachment and resource guarding by periodically replacing familiar toys with new ones.

Keeping the toys interesting and new, this tactic promotes a more peaceful play environment.

6. Individualized Playtime

Possessiveness can be reduced by allotting specific playtime for every dog.

Spending quality time with every dog separately not only improves your relationship but also lessens the need for rivalry over toys.

Their need for interaction is satisfied, which lessens their possessive tendencies.

7. Gradual Toy Introduction

Do it gradually and under supervision when introducing a new toy to a group of dogs.

Start by letting each dog inspect and sniff the toy on their own. Allow them to play together under supervision once they are both at ease.

This strategy guarantees a more seamless transition and lessens the possibility of possessive behavior.

8. Engage in Interactive Play

Playing interactively with your dogs can help them focus on something other than being possessive.

They can change their focus from protecting toys to the game by engaging in fetch or tug-of-war.

To keep play sessions fun and conflict-free, remember to supervise and lead them.

9. Seek Professional Guidance

It may be helpful to seek the advice of a qualified dog trainer or behaviorist if your dog’s possessiveness toward its toys persists in spite of your efforts.

These professionals can evaluate the particular dynamics between your dogs and offer specialized guidance to successfully address the possessiveness issue.

Tips for Preventing Dog Possessive of Toys With Other Dogs

Here are some common tips for preventing toy possessiveness in dogs:

1. Start early: Begin socializing your dog with other dogs and toys from a young age to prevent possessive tendencies from developing.
2. Positive Reinforcement: Teach your dog that good behavior will result in positive outcomes. Reward them with treats or praise when they share their toys or exhibit non-possessive behavior.
3. Teach “Drop it” Command: Teach your dog to drop objects on command. Use positive reinforcement when they comply with the command.
4. Rotate Toys: Regularly rotate the toys to prevent your dog from becoming too attached to one specific toy.
5. Avoid Competition: Avoid situations that could lead to competition between dogs. Provide each dog their own set of toys to avoid competition for resources.
6. Supervision: Supervise your dog when they are playing with their toys, especially if there are other dogs or children around.
7. Consistency: Be consistent with your expectations and make sure everyone interacting with the dog follows the same rules.
8. No Tug-of-War: Avoid games like tug-of-war that can encourage possessive behavior.
9. Teach Sharing: Teach your dog to share by offering a toy and then taking it back. Repeat this process so they learn to share their toys.
10. No Punishment: Avoid punishing your dog for possessive behavior. This can make the behavior worse and erode their trust in you.

These are just some tips to help prevent toy possessiveness in dogs. If the behavior persists or worsens, it’s best to consult a professional dog trainer or behaviorist for help.

Learn more about resident dogs being aggressive with other dogs.

Related Questions

Why do dogs become possessive of toys around other dogs? A: Dogs can become possessive of toys around other dogs because they see the toy as a valuable resource that they need to protect. This behavior may be exacerbated in dogs that have a history of resource guarding or haven’t had enough positive experiences sharing toys with other dogs.

Can possessive behavior around toys lead to aggression in dogs?

Yes, possessive behavior around toys can lead to aggression in dogs. This is because the dog may feel threatened or protective of their toy and may lash out if they think another dog is trying to take it. It’s important to address possessive behavior before it escalates into aggression.

What should I do if my dog becomes possessive of toys during playtime with other dogs?

If your dog becomes possessive of toys during playtime with other dogs, interrupt the behavior and separate the dogs for a short period of time. Once your dog has calmed down, reintroduce them to playtime and continue to supervise their interactions.

Are there any toys that I should avoid giving to possessive dogs?

Yes, you should avoid giving possessive dogs toys that they may perceive as high-value or prize possessions. Toys that are small, squeaky, or can be easily destroyed may trigger possessive behavior. Instead, opt for toys that are durable and larger in size.

Do dogs only become possessive of toys around other dogs?

No, dogs can become possessive of toys around humans as well. It’s important to always supervise playtime and teach your dog appropriate toy-sharing behavior whether they’re playing with other dogs or with people.

Learn more about dogs licking other dogs’ faces.

Conclusion

In conclusion, it’s important to remember that dogs are possessive creatures, especially when it comes to their toys.

While it’s natural for them to want to protect their belongings, it’s also important for us as their owners to intervene and ensure that everyone plays nicely.

By creating a safe and controlled environment, we can help our furry friends learn how to share and coexist peacefully with their doggy pals.

So, next time you see your pup getting snappy over a toy, don’t get too worried – just step in and help them learn the art of sharing.